The "Bad Girl" Tag: When A Woman's Freedom Becomes A Threat To Society

Add as a preferred source on Google

"A good woman is expected to obey. A bold woman dares to feel." How often do we hear this - "She's changed." or "She's not the same good girl anymore."?

Society has always had a sharp eye for women who think freely, speak their truth, or live life on their own terms. From the clothes they wear to the way they love, every choice is examined under the moral microscope. And the label they get for doing something as simple as following their heart? - "Bad girl."

Recently, I watched a film called Bad Girl, a Tamil movie that left a strange ache inside me. It wasn't just a story on screen; it was a reflection of how countless women - including me - have lived, felt, and been judged.

The Story That Hit Home

The movie revolves around Ramya, a middle-class Tamilian girl studying in school. Her father works in another city, her mother is a teacher, and her grandmother - the forever critical matriarch - makes life even more suffocating. Ramya can't sleep at night; she spends her quiet hours dreaming - about romance, love, and a partner who would understand her.

While watching, I suddenly felt a strange connection with Ramya. She reminded me of my teenage self - a girl full of dreams, love, and the desire to have that "perfect soulmate" life. Like Ramya, I too fell in love young. Like her, I also lost it too soon.

When I was separated from my childhood love, I remember demanding my father to shift me to a hostel - not because I wanted independence, but because I didn't want to live under the suffocating silence of my home. That decision, though painful, became my first taste of freedom.

Freedom came with its own price. Society doesn't like girls who know what they want. Desiring love, expressing emotions, or speaking your mind automatically pushes you into the "bad" category.

The Conditioning Of 'Good' And 'Bad'

From the time we are little, Indian girls are handed invisible manuals of how to be a "good girl."

Be polite. Smile more. Don't argue. Serve others before yourself. And above all, never question the men around you. Our mothers and grandmothers, too, lived under the same manual. They were taught that serving hot rotis to their husbands and in-laws was the truest form of love. Generations of women have learned to measure their worth in how well they can please others - not how fulfilled they are inside.

"We teach our daughters to shrink themselves, to make themselves smaller. We say to girls: You can have ambition, but not too much."
- Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

I've seen this hypocrisy unfold up close. Back in Kanpur, I used to visit a friend's house after English classes. Her family was lively - everyone laughing, talking, teasing. But the moment her father's cycle parked outside the verandah, everything changed. Laughter stopped. Conversations ended. Silence took over. It was like someone turned off the light.

It shocked me because my own home was different. We waited eagerly for my father to come home. When he entered, the house filled with joy - we laughed, ate together, shared stories. But as I grew older, I realized that my friend's house wasn't an exception - it was the norm in many Indian homes.

A wife's silence was mistaken for respect.
A daughter-in-law's obedience was celebrated as virtue.
And a woman's dreams? - often dismissed as naïve or unnecessary.

Why Freedom Scares Society

A woman who speaks her mind challenges the very foundation on which patriarchy stands - control.

When a woman starts choosing how to live, whom to love, what to wear, and when to walk away, she becomes unpredictable. And for a society built on predictability and submission, that's terrifying. Freedom is not rebellion - it's self-respect.

But society translates that freedom as arrogance, immorality, or selfishness. According to a 2023 Pew Research Center survey, nearly 70% of Indian adults believe that women should "always obey their husbands." That's not just a statistic - it's a mirror of how deeply obedience is glorified over individuality.

The Mother-Daughter Loop

The movie "Bad Girl" beautifully captures the quiet suffering of two generations of women. Ramya's mother, a teacher, follows every societal rule - and yet feels incomplete. She too starts therapy by the end of the film, trying to untangle the guilt and expectations that swallowed her identity.

It's heartbreaking to see how trauma passes silently from one generation of women to another. Mothers, who once sacrificed their dreams, often end up teaching their daughters the same rules - not because they want to suppress them, but because they want to protect them from judgment. But here's the truth - protection that kills self-expression isn't protection; it's imprisonment.

According to a 2024 Mint report, there's been a 52% rise in women seeking therapy in urban India - most citing "identity suppression" and "relationship pressure."

The Symbolism Of The Cat

The movie ends with Ramya living alone with her cat. In Indian culture, cats are often considered bad luck, mysterious, or inauspicious. But isn't it ironic that cats represent everything society fears in women?

They are independent, self-loving, and unapologetic. They don't obey commands; they choose affection on their terms.

That's exactly what free-spirited women do - they decide how to love, when to stay, and when to walk away. And that makes them "bad" in the eyes of those who only understand control. "Like a cat, a woman's love cannot be demanded. It must be invited."

Being The 'Bad Girl' In A Good World

Maybe being a "bad girl" isn't bad after all. It means choosing yourself without guilt. It means walking away from noise, and standing for what feels right. It means saying no when silence is expected.

Every woman who ever dreamed differently - from Ramya to you, to me - is a "bad girl" in someone's story. And that's okay. Because bad girls are the ones who change narratives, question systems, and inspire other women to live freely.

"Well-behaved women seldom make history."
- Laurel Thatcher Ulrich

A Girl Who Wanted Love, Not Permission

When I think of Ramya's journey - her sleepless nights, her rebellion, her quiet loneliness - I don't see a "bad girl." I see a girl who just wanted to live authentically. A girl who wanted love, not permission.

In a society that fears independent women, the most radical thing you can do is be yourself - loudly, lovingly, unapologetically. So the next time someone calls you a "bad girl," smile and say - "Thank you." Because that means you're living your truth.