The 90-Hour Work Week Debate : Are You Living To Work Or Working To Live?

Add as a preferred source on Google

Would you work 90 hours a week, or sacrifice your 'me' time and family moments on Sundays to be more productive at work? For many workaholics, passion and ambition drive them to push boundaries, believing that dedication and hard work are essential for success.

But should this come at the cost of your health and relationships? Is work truly the only important aspect of life? These questions lie at the heart of a growing debate on work-life balance and the true meaning of productivity.

Recently, the call for a 90-hour work week by L&T (Larsen & Toubro) Chairman SN Subrahmanyan has ignited a fiery debate in India, challenging the long-standing conversation about work-life balance.

This proposition has not only polarised opinions within the corporate world but has also spilled over into politics, entertainment, and the broader public discourse.

Photo Credit: PTI

SN Subrahmanyan's Call For A 90-Hour Work Week

L&T Chairman SN Subrahmanyan sparked widespread controversy with his advocacy for a 90-hour work week, including working on Sundays. His suggestion aimed to boost productivity and reflect ambition within the workforce. Subrahmanyan's remarks implied that extended working hours are essential for driving economic growth and development, even if it means sacrificing personal time.

The Controversial 'Sun-duty' Proposal

Subrahmanyan's views on working through Sundays, jokingly dubbed "Sun-duty" by critics have drawn significant backlash. This idea of turning what is traditionally a day of rest into a regular workday was seen as a stark departure from the emphasis on maintaining a work-life balance. The notion of 'Sun-duty' has been particularly contentious, symbolising a broader push towards a relentless work culture that prioritises hours worked over employee wellbeing.

A Divisive Perspective

While Subrahmanyan defended his stance as a reflection of L&T's commitment to nation-building and ambition, his comments have ignited a debate about the value of quality versus quantity in the workplace. His perspective contrasts sharply with global movements towards shorter work weeks and better work-life balance, highlighting a fundamental disagreement on how best to achieve productivity and growth.

Corporate Leaders Push Back

Prominent business figures like Harsh Goenka, Anand Mahindra, and Harsh Mariwala have voiced strong opposition. They advocate for quality over quantity, warning against the detrimental effects of overwork. Their stand aligns with global trends promoting balanced work environments for sustainable growth and employee wellbeing.

Global Lessons And Domestic Realities

Drawing parallels with post-war Japan and Germany, proponents of extended hours argue for its necessity in economic reconstruction. However, critics highlight the adverse effects seen in countries like Japan, where overwork has contributed to societal issues such as an ageing population and declining birth rates.

Health Risks And Productivity Myths

Experts warn about the health risks associated with long working hours. Studies by the WHO and ILO show a higher risk of severe health issues for those exceeding 55 hours per week. The tragic case of Anna Sebastian Perayil brings this issue closer to home, underscoring the urgent need to prioritise employee health.

Photo Credit: https://www.instagram.com/deepikapadukone

Voices From Politics And Entertainment

Politicians like MP Mahua Moitra and MP Priyanka Chaturvedi have criticised the proposal for promoting outdated work ethics. Celebrities, including Deepika Padukone, have also weighed in, stressing the importance of mental health and a balanced life.

The Economic Perspective : Quality Over Quantity

Economists like Rathin Roy and Lekha S Chakraborty argue that productivity is driven by efficient use of time rather than sheer hours worked. The focus should shift towards enhancing working conditions and wages to boost output and employee satisfaction.

A Balanced Approach : The Need Of The Hour

As many countries explore shorter work weeks to combat burnout, India's debate on extended hours appears regressive. The conversation underscores the necessity of balancing ambition with wellbeing, ensuring that employee health is not sacrificed for economic gains.

The backlash against the 90-hour work week proposal highlights a critical turning point in India's corporate culture. It's time for a paradigm shift that recognises the importance of mental health, work-life balance, and quality over mere hours. The path to sustainable success lies not in overwork, but in creating environments where employees thrive both personally and professionally.